Blue Origin CEO Jeff Bezos (pictured) and SpaceX CEO Elon Musk are competing for dominance of the industrial spaceflight trade. Credit score: Blue Origin.
The billionaire space race between Jeff Bezos’ Blue Origin and Elon Musk’s SpaceX has taken a dramatic flip.
Final week, Blue Origin filed a public comment to the FAA requesting that the regulator restrict the variety of launches of SpaceX’s Starship—the biggest and strongest rocket ever constructed—out of Launch Complicated-39A at Kennedy Area Middle in Florida, which at present hosts the corporate’s Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy rockets.
The FAA in Might launched a SpaceX proposal for high-frequency Starship operations at Kennedy, together with the development of infrastructure that may permit Musk’s agency to finish 44 launches per yr.
The submitting is the newest wrinkle within the multiyear feud between Musk and Bezos, who’ve exchanged taunts and legal actions as they battle for supremacy within the industrial spaceflight trade. Each SpaceX and Blue Origin have obtained contracts from U.S. authorities businesses resembling NASA and the Pentagon and intend to make cosmic tourism a chunk of their enterprise.
“Sue Origin,” Musk bantered on social media platform X, which he acquired in 2022.
In a subsequent post, the SpaceX boss added, “An clearly disingenuous response. Not cool of them to attempt (for the third time) to impede SpaceX’s progress by lawfare.”
The general public remark filed by Blue Origin has no authorized bearing, however the FAA will consider it because it determines what restrictions to position on Starship at Kennedy.
SpaceX is searching for a industrial launch automobile operator license for Starship operations at Launch Complicated 39-A, which would require the preparation of an environmental influence assertion (EIS). The EIS describes the potential results of these operations on the encompassing setting and was required for SpaceX to start the Starship orbital test flight program, for instance. SpaceX will put together the evaluation itself underneath FAA supervision.
Throughout Starship’s maiden voyage, which resulted in a ball of flames a couple of minutes into the mission, the influence from the launch precipitated sudden harm so far as 6 miles away from the Starbase launchpad in Boca Chica, Texas. The pressure of Starship broke home windows, despatched ashy particles into the sky, and introduced an FAA investigation into SpaceX’s environmental mitigations, grounding the rocket for months. 5 environmental teams sued the FAA over its dealing with of the mission.
Since then, SpaceX has made several improvements to Starbase to include Starship’s particles discipline, and subsequent missions have resulted in little fanfare. Nonetheless, it seems Blue Origin will use the incident as leverage in its plea to the FAA.
“At Starbase, Starship and Tremendous Heavy take a look at missions have been topic to environmental scrutiny attributable to their influence on the native setting and neighborhood,” the general public remark reads, citing the aforementioned lawsuit in opposition to the regulator as proof.
Blue Origin too launches operations out of Kennedy. The corporate leases Area Launch Complicated-36 and occupies a number of hangars, in addition to a producing web site, at Cape Canaveral Area Pressure Station (CCSFS), which it says are near the realm SpaceX desires to make use of.
“Blue Origin employs over 2,700 full-time staff in [Florida’s] Brevard County, together with 449 staff at CCSFS which can be instantly impacted by native launch actions,” the submitting reads. “Blue Origin has invested greater than $1 billion in capital expenditures to develop [Launch Complex-36] as the primary privately constructed heavy-lift launch advanced on this planet.”
The corporate mentioned it worries in regards to the security of property and personnel throughout a Starship launch anomaly, resembling an explosion, fireplace, particles, or loud noise. It additionally argued that Starship operations may impede Blue Origin’s entry to shared infrastructure and “restricted airspace and maritime sources.”
Starship and the Tremendous Heavy booster maintain about 5,200 metric tons of liquid methane for propulsion—the pressure of which, Blue Origin claims, would impede firm and authorities actions at Kennedy as a result of anticipated requirement of a security margin across the web site.
The agency urged the FAA to position a cap on the variety of Starship launches, specify and restrict launch occasions, and spend money on infrastructure that may make Kennedy and CCSFS safer and extra accessible for different launch suppliers.
It additionally prompt that SpaceX and the federal government be required to compensate Blue Origin or different corporations whose industrial actions are impacted by Starship, in addition to obligatory penalties for SpaceX ought to it violate the EIS or its license.
Given Bezos’ historical past with Musk, it’s troublesome to say whether or not real concern, a need to hamper the competitors, or each prompted the remark.
Blue Origin is creating an alternative choice to Starship, New Glenn, however the rocket has faced delays and has but to fly. New Glenn has collected a handful of consumers, together with Amazon’s Challenge Kuiper and NASA, which intends to launch it to Mars on its maiden voyage later this yr.
NASA was on the middle of probably the most publicized dispute between Blue Origin and SpaceX. After the area company tapped SpaceX as the only supplier of a human touchdown system (HLS) for Artemis missions to the moon, Bezos in 2021 took NASA to court docket, arguing that it had promised two contracts
The corporate would ultimately lose that battle. However the area company in 2023 announced Blue Origin because the second Artemis HLS supplier. Each corporations are actually working with NASA to develop a revamped plan for the Mars Pattern Return Program, every receiving a $1.5 million contract.
The companies are additionally competing within the navy sphere. In 2022, Blue Origin misplaced out on a pair of Pentagon contracts on the expense of SpaceX and United Launch Alliance, a three way partnership between Boeing and Lockheed Martin. However earlier this month, it secured its own agreement with the U.S. Area Pressure for 30 navy launches, price as much as $5.6 billion.
This article was first published on FLYINGMAG.com
Like this story? We expect you’ll additionally just like the Future of FLYING newsletter despatched each Thursday afternoon. Sign up now.
